Microsoft gave the world a peak at what their next OS, Windows 7, would look like at the All Things D conference. On the heels of Surface and it's multi-touch input, Microsoft decided to bring the technology to consumers sooner by adding it to 7.
Video: Multi-Touch in Windows 7
Never mind how single-touch a la tablets flopped, the applications for dual-touch are even more limited. Most are at best nifty, but one of these novelties is so bad, it reverses years of advancements: the multi-touch photo browser. Not only does the photo browser let users circumvent a selling point of technology and disorganize their photos, it offers only marginal benefits over a stack of photos on a coffee table.
Which brings us back to Surface, which I admit is quite nifty.
Thursday, May 29, 2008
Wednesday, April 16, 2008
Reason #1 startups fail: software underestimates
A friend sent me a link about a programmer who was approached by friends to work on a startup, only to find that they thought his role was so easy, he'd do it for free.
Between budgets, man-hours, and even CPU requirements, underestimating how long software takes to write and test is easy. And it's not only a problem for startups, companies like Microsoft have the same problem--Vista wasn't just late, it was missing features. The good news for startups is that deadlines and requirements are often flexible, but missed deadlines kill morale.
Basically, the only people worse at estimating software schedules than programmers are managers, and the only people worse at dealing with missed deadlines than managers are programmers.
Between budgets, man-hours, and even CPU requirements, underestimating how long software takes to write and test is easy. And it's not only a problem for startups, companies like Microsoft have the same problem--Vista wasn't just late, it was missing features. The good news for startups is that deadlines and requirements are often flexible, but missed deadlines kill morale.
Basically, the only people worse at estimating software schedules than programmers are managers, and the only people worse at dealing with missed deadlines than managers are programmers.
Thursday, April 10, 2008
Former Lycos CEO on the startup market
Why is it that CEOs who cashed out of failed companies early end up becomming VCs? No matter. Kara Swisher of All Things D interviewed former Lycos CEO Bob Davis, hoping for a few bits on wisdom.
So what's a relatively new VC do, now? Shamelessly promote a startup he funded, Quattro Wireless, that reformats the web for mobile phones and provides ads for web-enabled mobile phones. Their problem is that they're the WebTV of Web 2.0, and while trying to start an ad network--an revenue source--is admirable, if monetizing the web is hard, imagine trying to monetize a platform that isn't used for purchasing, has far less traffic, and far less space for ads. Amazon.com predates Adsense by several years. Maybe people should figure out what people are selling via phones before they start building advertising platforms.
Here's where Davis gets something right: when asked what's overhyped, he responded with the natural "social networking." More interesting was his take on social networking 1.0. He looks back on Lycos acquisitions Tripod and Angelfire as the Facebooks of their day. What's changing isn't the technology--neither the web, Facebook, or Google did anything to add to the internet--it's that the internet is changing from being generalized to being specific. Someone using his 1998 Geocities homepage to post personal information, a résumé, family photos, and a his research on Mark Twain would today use Facebook, LinkedIn, Flickr, and Wikipedia to do the same things. Generalized tools might be powerful, but only specialized tools find an audience.
"I think there is a big, big play to be made in the mobile arena, [but] ...people have not figured out where it's going to be. Look at the raw number of handsets...As it relates to content, no one has put it together, yet"Platform matters. Remember WebTV? It was (and barely still is) a set top box paired with a keyboard for browsing websites on TVs. Despite the potentially large audience and the built-in market of newcomers to the internet, it never caught on. WebTV was a nifty idea, but Tivo is what brought TV and the web together, taking features from each component, and solving a problem that affected people.
So what's a relatively new VC do, now? Shamelessly promote a startup he funded, Quattro Wireless, that reformats the web for mobile phones and provides ads for web-enabled mobile phones. Their problem is that they're the WebTV of Web 2.0, and while trying to start an ad network--an revenue source--is admirable, if monetizing the web is hard, imagine trying to monetize a platform that isn't used for purchasing, has far less traffic, and far less space for ads. Amazon.com predates Adsense by several years. Maybe people should figure out what people are selling via phones before they start building advertising platforms.
Here's where Davis gets something right: when asked what's overhyped, he responded with the natural "social networking." More interesting was his take on social networking 1.0. He looks back on Lycos acquisitions Tripod and Angelfire as the Facebooks of their day. What's changing isn't the technology--neither the web, Facebook, or Google did anything to add to the internet--it's that the internet is changing from being generalized to being specific. Someone using his 1998 Geocities homepage to post personal information, a résumé, family photos, and a his research on Mark Twain would today use Facebook, LinkedIn, Flickr, and Wikipedia to do the same things. Generalized tools might be powerful, but only specialized tools find an audience.
Saturday, March 29, 2008
Monetization is hard
Web 2.0 wasn't proclaimed a bubble for any of the criteria that define a speculative bubble. Valuations aren't particularly crazy (few startups have sold or had an IPO), there isn't any "flipping" or speculation, and there aren't many people outside of the industry involved. People saw what was going on and recognized the South Park gnome business plan that dominated the 90s. Startups were sporting spiffy UIs, large userbases, but now, found a way to make money: ads.
Only it wasn't that easy. Take Facebook. In a Motley Fool piece, one fool had this to say:
Or take an anonymous startup that's essentially many niche forums. They know what their users are interested in, but there isn't an advertising platform that has relevant, niche products, and a lot of advertisers are only interested in US pageviews. When they turned to adsense as a last resort, they were making $500 a day, but for 50 million page views.
Simply gathering pageviews, even by the millions, isn't enough to turn a reasonable profit. What's worse, what value these startups have isn't in their technology, but in their use. These startups are more apt to see new competitors than an acquisition--becoming devalued is more likely than growing.
Only it wasn't that easy. Take Facebook. In a Motley Fool piece, one fool had this to say:
Since some of the finest marketing minds in the world have tried and largely failed to monetize social networking already, I see many years of losses and negative cash flows ahead for Facebook.Google was able to monetize search because of the nature of search. If you're looking for information on digital cameras, there's a decent chance you're in the market for a digital camera, so an appropriate ad is shown. Social networks, on the other hand, despite having detailed information about you, aren't complementing their service with ads, but their service is instead competing with ads.
Or take an anonymous startup that's essentially many niche forums. They know what their users are interested in, but there isn't an advertising platform that has relevant, niche products, and a lot of advertisers are only interested in US pageviews. When they turned to adsense as a last resort, they were making $500 a day, but for 50 million page views.
Simply gathering pageviews, even by the millions, isn't enough to turn a reasonable profit. What's worse, what value these startups have isn't in their technology, but in their use. These startups are more apt to see new competitors than an acquisition--becoming devalued is more likely than growing.
Wednesday, March 26, 2008
My best startup advice
Strange for this to be such an early post in the blog--you'd think epiphanies like this would come later--but it's certainly useful early on.
Solve a problem that affects you.
Look at open source software; the developers are driven by a common problem, not by money (but perhaps recognition). Define success as making your life easier and gaining experience. You'll gain more--in both experience and recognition--through the completion of a profitless startup than by abandoning a potentially profitable one. Yes, a business model is great, but don't focus too much on it. A business model doesn't define a good idea; it's just a criterion for a potentially profitable idea.
Solve a problem that affects you.
Look at open source software; the developers are driven by a common problem, not by money (but perhaps recognition). Define success as making your life easier and gaining experience. You'll gain more--in both experience and recognition--through the completion of a profitless startup than by abandoning a potentially profitable one. Yes, a business model is great, but don't focus too much on it. A business model doesn't define a good idea; it's just a criterion for a potentially profitable idea.
Monday, March 24, 2008
Platform matters
The Facebook application platform didn't do anything particularly new. Take Scrabulous, a top 10 Facebook app. Games associated with friends lists are far from new; AOL, ICQ, and others all tried variants of this idea in Bubble 1.0, but none of them were able to bring IM to be more than just messaging. Even without integration, sending a friend a link to Yahoo Games wasn't a barrier preventing consumers from playing online games.
Importance of platforms is nothing new. IM took users from email, mp3 took users from CDs, and so on. What you're doing matters as much as where you're doing it, and certain platforms do a better job facilitating tasks than others. This isn't to say Facebook is the alpha-platform. Facebook may be moving into the IM market, they'll undoubtedly see stiff competition from existing services, as well as web services, and while their entry into the email market didn't go unnoticed, "Messages" hardly displaced email.
Presentation is as important as function. Not only are numerous startups, e.g. Meebo, based entirely on presentation, but superior presentation can quickly displace even a 5-year lead in time to market.
Importance of platforms is nothing new. IM took users from email, mp3 took users from CDs, and so on. What you're doing matters as much as where you're doing it, and certain platforms do a better job facilitating tasks than others. This isn't to say Facebook is the alpha-platform. Facebook may be moving into the IM market, they'll undoubtedly see stiff competition from existing services, as well as web services, and while their entry into the email market didn't go unnoticed, "Messages" hardly displaced email.
Presentation is as important as function. Not only are numerous startups, e.g. Meebo, based entirely on presentation, but superior presentation can quickly displace even a 5-year lead in time to market.
Sunday, March 16, 2008
About the title
I owe Valleywag editor Owen Thomas a drink for the blog title. It's his word (even if he wish he never coined it; I just couldn't think of a better name).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)